log☇︎
577700+ entries in 0.352s
jurov: they saved on high tech to buy grain, i can esily see it
mircea_popescu: generally, the leadership of "socii", ie "allies" ie vassals is worse than at the center.
mircea_popescu: jurov czechoslovakia isn't soviet russia tho or what are we talking about here
[]bot: Bet placed: 1 BTC for No on "BTC network hashrate will exceed 1 Exahash/s before June 2015" http://bitbet.us/bet/1074/ Odds: 3(Y):97(N) by coin, 3(Y):97(N) by weight. Total bet: 1.1 BTC. Current weight: 99,993.
[]bot: Bet placed: 1.25 BTC for Yes on "S.MPOE to trade <= 25000 satoshis before April" http://bitbet.us/bet/1075/ Odds: 95(Y):5(N) by coin, 95(Y):5(N) by weight. Total bet: 1.35 BTC. Current weight: 99,991.
jurov: well, clearly they had their priorities
jurov: it was cuz they bought grain instead?
jurov: my grandpa was technical manager in 1980s and explained the hoops they had to jump to buy any equipment from the west
mircea_popescu: iirc their balance of trade was <10% of their gdp
jurov: even if that meant debt?
mircea_popescu: as a result of the canadian explosion.
mircea_popescu: by 1980 the globalisation of trade makes such approach useless.
jurov: yes, ussr imports in the 1980s. there was modern agriculture and irrigation available then, i suppose?
mircea_popescu: jurov you mean in the 80s ?
mircea_popescu: jurov and if you also count greece as part of europe, they had a famine tambien.
assbot: Foreign trade of the Soviet Union - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia ... ( http://bit.ly/1y9zs0H )
mircea_popescu: nah, the famines were criminal particularly because stalin's soviets were net exporters.
jurov: from the west, even.
jurov: afaik ussr had to import grain *consistently*
mircea_popescu: pretty much like the russian.
mircea_popescu: whioch reminds me. asciilifeform you know the irish "fear gortha" ?
mircea_popescu: <jurov> and there was no such famine in eastern eutope outside russia inn 20th century << silesia famine in 1850 ? hongerwinter ?
mircea_popescu: that's the clear and incontrovertible proof that mechanized agriculture wasn't available even beyond the pale. let alone inside russia proper.
mircea_popescu: <jurov> and it was *after* mechanized agriculture was available << it was not at all available. do you know what the tachanka was ? Makhno's thing.
mircea_popescu: <bagels7> they didnt have tchonology like today? <<< they didn't need it, because they weren't nearly as many.
mircea_popescu: they don't like it, let them displace the other half.
mircea_popescu: <asciilifeform> detectably plenty of starvation in ancient world, even with 'sound money' and good management << quite. famine is a great motivator, and to be honest i do not see why half the population should not at all points be hungry.
[]bot: Bet created: "S.MPOE to trade <= 25000 satoshis before April" http://bitbet.us/bet/1075/
assbot: The idea for a great film... pe Trilema - Un blog de Mircea Popescu. ... ( http://bit.ly/1FllE3z )
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: 'the west gate fell. all is lost.' that one
mircea_popescu: which one is that one ?
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: also tied in to your 'then the centurion walks in, a different kind of man' story.
mircea_popescu: the substance of the squal of the little girl confronted with the underside of a large boulder exposed to air
mircea_popescu: the entire "putin doesn't understand how thwe world works" and "oh horror x! oh horror y!" is really the voice of a deconstructed postmodern intellect confronted with the sheer obscenity of reality.
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: aha. in the words of herr kokkarinen: 'modern hipster is not being rogered, because the cock is entering ironically(tm)'
mircea_popescu: this sort of ablated hipsterism is what passes for strategic thinking in the us.
mircea_popescu: and nobody could conceivably wish to do anything *seriously*
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: but i brought it up on account of 'orcs' rather than gulag. what orcs look like to human.
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform "but nobody would dare sink a carrier, because THEN ITD MEAN THEYRE SERIOUS ANBD FOR REAL!!!!"
asciilifeform: jurov: u.s. gulag system, afaik, is merely an expensive waste of time, like their aircraft carriers.
assbot: Un prophète pe Trilema - Un blog de Mircea Popescu. ... ( http://bit.ly/1y9vEMZ )
asciilifeform: the one with 'height of the tallest building' ?
jurov: i'm confudes now...if its' a good thing, you should then admire the US for its gulag system
asciilifeform: to a 'human', what can be more revolting than an 'orc.' now where was that prison film review by mircea_popescu ?
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform yet the us seems to be bringing it a whole lot these days lol
undata: mircea_popescu: the southern cock will rise again!
asciilifeform: but 'orcs suck and should simply kill themselves instead of sullying the planet with their stench' is not a historical argument.
asciilifeform: there is also the 'they're idiot orcs' construction. which isn't even false, because, well, orcs.
mircea_popescu: undata just look at how the southerners were coerce to become yanks after the war.
undata: *property taxes
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform at least, this;'d be the "most favourable possible ulterior retrospective construction"
undata: asciilifeform: I see that; in the US many tactics were used, among them property tactics, etc., to coerce people into the cities
asciilifeform: ultimately, being a builder of industry at the 1917 (or even today's) tech level, fundamentally sucks. as in, the same way being in prison sucks. so stalin et. al. tried experiment: what if being a peasant sucked -more- ? and - it worked. ☟︎
mircea_popescu: why did i kill andreas derpopo for that matter ?
mircea_popescu: then you can see a line there.
mircea_popescu: if he makes it whole and says "without the gulags, from congo to CAR"
mircea_popescu: jurov well, his argument was that from plow to nuke.
asciilifeform: undata: basic mechanics here. peasants do not actually need the city-dwellers for anything (at least at the ru circa 1917 tech level.) why should they feed them, if asked nicely? and why would they wish to move to the city and waste away in factories, merely if asked nicely?
mircea_popescu: but hey, viagra plugged that hole.
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform perhaps because it is the case.
mircea_popescu: because if you don't then by your definitions eugenics, and if you do wtf you doing in slovakia instead of say b-a.
undata: were gulags needed to organize peasants into industrial workers?
mircea_popescu: jurov do you believe that out of two possible situations, the one with more people in it is always best ?
undata: I suppose it depends on the situation as to how much of a display is needed
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: in the land of 'soft power' - soft gulag. (almost inevitably hands want to say 'soft cocks' also.)
undata: mircea_popescu: I see the point about a genuine display of power
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform what is us academia if not exactly this ?
asciilifeform: there is every reason to expect this behaviour from future meat grinders.
ben_vulpes: undata: if you're taking home more than 16.5K as an individual, it's not cheaper.
asciilifeform: jurov: incidentally, the most well-founded historical model of gulag etc. i know of is - that meat grinder was built, and became the proverbial 'self-licking icecream cone' after running short on the designated feedstock. a la french rev.
mircea_popescu: by definition you know ? if you're not hurtin yourself then why wouldn't it be fake.
mircea_popescu: <undata> this to me sounds like a very wealthy man lighting his wealth on fire to display sovereignty << afaik the only possible honest signal is exactly this.
jurov: asciilifeform: here they did like kolkhozs to an amount bacuse it wasn't done so violently
asciilifeform: jurov: and realize that the blowback from present-day usg idiocy will make lenin et. al. look reasonable and gentle. see earlier thread re: isis.
undata: this to me sounds like a very wealthy man lighting his wealth on fire to display sovereignty
undata: surely you need *some* population or what's this sovereignty over?
mircea_popescu: <cazalla> bagels7: the beatings were way worse than any bdsm "master" i had <<< lol same << lol wait, bagels7 is into bdsm ?
undata: mircea_popescu: not-maximizing isn't the same as actively grinding away at your population until as jurov points out the numbers start to really dwindle
asciilifeform: jurov: try to see the difference between 'i like kolkhoz' and 'what they did, made sense'.
mircea_popescu: <asciilifeform> jurov: maximizing meat now? << as far as i can tell, there's a certain subgroup of transhumanists for whom even the faintest hint of discussion as to whether rivers of meat is the correct minimaxing is "eugenics" which is to say their local equivalent of "fascist" ie, very bad mkay.
jurov: yes, that's what i mean
asciilifeform: jurov: amateur gardens, yes. the traditional 100 sq. metres.
jurov: lenin could do that in 1918
jurov: yes it is obvious. there was no famine in the 1990s only because govt came to senses and gave people their own soil
assbot: Police horse study: Increases trust, authors say. ... ( http://bit.ly/1y9tE7t )
BingoBoingo: The Usian Gendarmie is probably going to have a lot of horses http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2014/11/19/police_horse_study_increases_trust_authors_say.html
asciilifeform: lol, that my drunken compatriots could not fend for themselves, is as obvious as gravity.
asciilifeform: jurov: feel free to travel back in time and teach lenin et. al. how to retain sovereignty for their country (that is, no colonization, no cultivation of dependence on hostile west) without, well, the cost.
jurov: asciilifeform just keeps coming with excuses why his drunkard compatriots can't fend for thmeselves so well
undata: this comes up a lot in here; why does that follow?
undata: asciilifeform: that a sovereign can do whatever he pleases doesn't necessarily proceed to "therefore he stole all my things and left me in mud"
jurov: germans made tanks too, and did not even had so much arable soil.. no famines there, too
asciilifeform: without sovereignty, 'your' tractor - isn't yours. it belongs (along with your starfish) to the big boys. ☟︎☟︎
jurov: and there was no such famine in eastern eutope outside russia inn 20th century
asciilifeform: jurov: tank is a particular type of tractor, let's say. it cultivates sovereignty (or did, in the age of the tank, but why nitpick) rather than edibles. ☟︎☟︎☟︎
undata: jurov: my folks grow enough to have everything they need, and the food they produce is delicious
jurov: if they could make tanks, why not tractors?
asciilifeform: jurov: available to whom? at what cost? tractors dropped from sky on demand?
undata: one of those being fucking until the pile of human flesh I've produced is visible from space
undata: asciilifeform: there are innumerable things I could do in the present moment that I don't because they don't seem sensible