log☇︎
571700+ entries in 0.371s
asciilifeform: (as they say in britain) 'a whole policeman!'
mircea_popescu: what can be said of the average policeman ?
mircea_popescu: and speaking of which, given that intelligence is to be measured in tsyans,
asciilifeform: sed income, but that is the price of freedom.'
asciilifeform: 'What this means in practice, for me at least, is that as soon as it starts looking like I am heading in the direction of acquiring a specific job title or job description, or getting involved in something that might require registration, certification or licensing, then I need to backtrack or head in a different direction for a bit, until everybody loses interest. In doing so I sometimes forgo some opportunities for an increa
asciilifeform struggles to make sense of the thing
mircea_popescu: i guess we progressed past the classical philosophy of either rome or the east. a well.
mircea_popescu: dude srsly, intelligent people want to go a direction ?
mircea_popescu: "I seem to be doing a lot of hyperproductive things lately: explaining to people how to kill the foul beast of Empire, revolutionizing the way English literacy is taught to both native English speakers and the rest"
asciilifeform: one untrained, equally irrespective of measured iq, is quite unpalatable << perhaps here speaking of taming, rather than training ?
asciilifeform: did establish that we're gnawing on the leather straps of english, i think.
mircea_popescu: so then.
asciilifeform: and when you practice this, yes, gets stronger. this is training intelligence - sure.
mircea_popescu: anyway, thus understood, you will find that a woman trained to be intelligent, irrespective of iq, is quite to your liking, whereas one untrained, equally irrespective of measured iq, is quite unpalatable.
mircea_popescu: same reason braided rope is stronger than straight rope.
mircea_popescu: nevertheless, experience shows pairs work better, because errors average out rather than compound.
mircea_popescu: one can train to build muscle by himself. one can also train to comprehend the torah by oneself.
asciilifeform: teach self to control emotion. and to grasp, e.g., group theor
mircea_popescu: nothing of them. they may develop myopia in time.
mircea_popescu: what the fuck do you think intelligence is other than the ~knowledge~ of what is noise in the psychocrosstalk ?
asciilifeform: what of the folks who are their own seal -and- circus trainer?
mircea_popescu: what else ? first you gotta teach her to rule over her emotions, then gotta teach her the modes of logical failure of teh brain, on it goes.
asciilifeform: training to think consists of pure 'don't do's? news to me.
mircea_popescu: as a result, there's nothing fucking scarier than the former known to man.
mircea_popescu: the difference is that the first's entirely negative (don't do this. don't do that. don't do the other. do something) while the latter's entirely positive. (do like this and like this and so on)
mircea_popescu: which is kind-of why people readily imagine training a woman to think with whip in hand and training a woman to dance whip in hand are the same thing.
mircea_popescu: same thing, for the exact reason you don't see much reading on tv.
mircea_popescu: to the ignorant, there's little difference between circus seal being trained and you sitting in room flipping page after page.
asciilifeform: hence why ballerinas are trained precisely like circus seals
asciilifeform: and there's exactly one way to train it
asciilifeform: cerebellum has to know
mircea_popescu: much of what YOU know is learned like what a dog learns. specifically, where the fuck the control key is and how to make pretty letters on the screen.
mircea_popescu: because well, they don't get wtf french is.
mircea_popescu: dressage has the unfortunate implication of dress-up in english
asciilifeform: pilot will readily concede that much of what he knows is trained like a dog is trained
mircea_popescu: hence well trained pilots, and training ai and so on
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: see, we always had separate words for these.
mircea_popescu: i think this pejorative usage is novel, and not really all that standard yet.
asciilifeform: that type of training is referred to as 'дрессировка'
decimation: asciilifeform: what I find amusing is the common practice is us business to use the word 'training' when they mean 'education'
asciilifeform: in the latter, a тренер is the fellow who helps an athlete get.. more athletic. in english world, 'training' is done to dogs and cubicle dwellers
BingoBoingo: <asciilifeform> if trained as in what a strong man in a circus does to get strong - then, yes, trained (but note, not every man can become a circus lifter) << Not every circus need be honest.
asciilifeform: incidentally, the word 'trained' - i found - means something quite else to english speakers than for folks from the sov blok
mircea_popescu: no, but every man can either become a circus lifter or die trying.
mircea_popescu: trained is what happened to scheherazade.
asciilifeform: if trained as in what a strong man in a circus does to get strong - then, yes, trained (but note, not every man can become a circus lifter)
mircea_popescu: but i did say that's not what's meant.
asciilifeform: if 'trained' is what one can do with a parrot - then, no, intelligence is something quite else
mircea_popescu: well so if all your intelligence is in fact trained, then what are ye bitching about.
asciilifeform: and, importantly, out of these how many are not actually in special-school-for-it << ding ding ding - winner
mircea_popescu: kinda lulzy when you visit a blog with one of those blinky geomaps, and the only blinky spot is in argentina.
BingoBoingo: 4-5 prolly. But yeah. May have to concede this point
assbot: Logged on 02-12-2014 15:10:06; asciilifeform: this is a subject that i have a little personal connection with. at one point, i spent almost two years of spare time working on what turned out to be 'fried ice'
asciilifeform: BingoBoingo: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=02-12-2014#942350 << in case you missed that thread. ☝︎
mircea_popescu: if you gotta use trainable tests you lost.
mircea_popescu: BingoBoingo how many women do you know that could do this ? and, importantly, out of these how many are not actually in special-school-for-it ?
BingoBoingo: Enough varied "trainable" questions though might approximate a test. Approximation probably necessary because jungle conditions.
asciilifeform: i worked with a whole mess of folks who could solve this one, for some value of 'solved'
BingoBoingo: Starting from a drawing of an catecholamine, draw a prototype for a drug that could antigonize the receptor for some sort of catecholamine neurotransmitter.
asciilifeform: they 'reproduce' by popping out of the zero point vacuum for a little while.
undata has learned that asciilifeforms reproduce by dividing
asciilifeform: well yes. you may have to devise a similarly peculiar example, if your friends read #b-a.
mircea_popescu: kind bad example cause didn't we discuss this here earlier ?
asciilifeform: and in none too great detail.
asciilifeform: considering the fact that no such item has been built, or, afaik, discussed, other than here by yours truly.
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: try this with one of your pets. tell her 'waveguide motor' and see if she is able to draw one that could, in principle, function. or at least say what such a thing would be.
BingoBoingo: asciilifeform: Sure trainable, yet... some fail to rediscover after learning in kindergarden when skill is summoned for video
asciilifeform: BingoBoingo: nope. trainable, because kindergarten homework.
BingoBoingo: asciilifeform> the easiest way to distinguish 'intelligent' and 'well-trained' is to invent something (sufficiently synthetic - as in, requiring grasp of multiple disparate and reasonably deep scientific fields) to apprehend, and then see how much explanation creature requires to grasp it. << bulb battery wire?
asciilifeform: if this is a 'muscle' that can be 'well trained' - this is not a 'margarine', but a 'real butter'. idempotent.
assbot: How dare the Eric Garner protestors dare try to disrupt a sacred ritual commemorating the birth a man who was murdered by the state.
asciilifeform: the easiest way to distinguish 'intelligent' and 'well-trained' is to invent something (sufficiently synthetic - as in, requiring grasp of multiple disparate and reasonably deep scientific fields) to apprehend, and then see how much explanation creature requires to grasp it.
mircea_popescu: most of the things one identifies as intelligence in the field is actually artfulness.
asciilifeform: not sure what, if anything, i might be surprised by (on this subject) if my bubble were larger.
mircea_popescu: but you're not free, being alive, and in that bound system you don't actually get enough elbow room to really find out.
asciilifeform: i may even have been to that circus.
mircea_popescu: in the world.
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: in the right kind of circus - absolutely
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform i'll bet you you couldn't discern between a well trained and an intelligent creature.
mircea_popescu: i suppose i should say "through the carrot", for elegance of form :D
asciilifeform: i'll volunteer that i can't easily lust over any creature detectably stupider than self.
decimation: mircea_popescu: perhaps not, but one can still measure them, and find that measures correlate
mircea_popescu: TomServo they're fundamental in the same way.
TomServo: How does beating relate to eating?
mircea_popescu: but no, the definition is i imagine quite ordinary.
asciilifeform: i suspect there is great variation
TomServo: mircea_popescu: Due to a lack of beatings, I haven't yet learned Romanian.
asciilifeform: actually, this is almost a fundamental question. like 'sexual orientation.' how many 'iq' points below yours (for a particular fellow) does 'zoophilia' begin ?
assbot: Cum se bate femeia ? pe Trilema - Un blog de Mircea Popescu. ... ( http://bit.ly/1vNSoBA )
TomServo: Is there some definition of beating I'm unaware of?
undata: I think this is predicated on "beat everyone"
decimation: TomServo: do you graduate from having to eat?
mircea_popescu: from the possibility thereof ?
asciilifeform: TomServo: it is possible to play the 'advanced' game, but you probably cannot assemble mircea_popescu's harem that way.
mircea_popescu: well ? what is this "advanced"
decimation: yeah yudkowsky and him co-wrote a paper on the 'ethics of artificial intelligence'
mircea_popescu: if she's advanced enough that she stops shitting
TomServo: mircea_popescu: no matter the level of advancement, always beat?
decimation: hehe yeah asciilifeform this guy has to be in yudkowsky's orbit somehow
asciilifeform: ^ current hitler of that sect