log☇︎
525300+ entries in 0.299s
asciilifeform: what if chlorophorm cost what the 'difference engine' cost.
mircea_popescu: this meta cancer upon the modern brain. people spend so much time considering "the implications" of shit that never happened they have no energy left to do stuff.
asciilifeform: see if effect can be had somewhere -left- of the eigth decimal
mircea_popescu: well it's certainly closer to being pursued after being measured than before eh.
asciilifeform: have the thing pursued
ben_vulpes: asciilifeform: walk where? wants grant money for himself as a result of the discovery?
mircea_popescu: all this nonsense of little girl stuck on the trans side of maturity river, discussing whether she wants to cross or not, what if the cis side won't be all that it's cracked up to be etc. wtf.
mircea_popescu: you will notice that the scam foundation is being fucking buried. in spite of... welll... consensus.
asciilifeform: which takes a few $b in imperial money
asciilifeform: al doesn't, as i understand, agree. he wants it to keep walking from there
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform that's it.
mircea_popescu: who the fuck cares what anyone else does ?
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: let's gedankenexperiment. say we build the thing and it runs as predicted (see the last chemistry.stackexchange link for what we'd be doing, roughly)
mircea_popescu: just measure the damned thing. if it doesn't come out, either refine the machinery or give up.
assbot: Logged on 27-11-2014 15:36:04; mircea_popescu: no wonder everyone in the us needs a college degree. there's no way native intelligence could deal with a tenth of the cognitive dissonance dished out on a daily basis.
mircea_popescu: the shit's hard enough without waiting for complex voodoo to allign.
mircea_popescu: i never heard of this bizarro shamanistic approach to research.
gabriel_laddel: If you're not strong enough now, retreat, lick your wounds and then strike when the time is right.
gabriel_laddel: As far as I can tell, it comes down to the basic strategic necessity of killing your enemy when you indend to.
asciilifeform: the legitimacy of the whole shebang is at stake
asciilifeform: if it doesn't exist, they'd rather not turn up anything
asciilifeform: aha see they are only interested in finding effect predicted by the usg-sponsored paper machine
gabriel_laddel: "1) Search for experimental signs of quantum gravity that violate Einstein's Equivalence Principle and/or the Newtonian inverse-square law."
asciilifeform: incidentally, he mentioned that other folks also offered to arrange, and he held off for same reason
assbot: HOME | The Eöt-Wash Group ... ( http://bit.ly/1CbzEAt )
gabriel_laddel: check this out http://www.npl.washington.edu/eotwash/
gabriel_laddel: mircea_popescu: but this is not germane to the issue. << Oh, but it is. These people are prepared to lie at every turn. See the stack overflow post, or the output of the Eot-wash group. If Al or Stan were make a mistake in the run, they'd never be able to test it again.
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: he thought (as of our last at-length exchange, ~3 yrs or so) that he still had a chance to make the torsion balance owners see the light
mircea_popescu: and the proponent can't be doing or not doing "because of other people" (tm)
asciilifeform: the actual matter here is 'what's one physical effect vs hundred thousand respectable careers of respectable people (tm)'
mircea_popescu: we're not discussing why some other blokes aren't testing it, we're discussing why the proponent isn't.
mircea_popescu: but this is not germane to the issue.
gabriel_laddel: but the grant funding people don't know this
asciilifeform: and failing to find difference
asciilifeform: they proclaimed 'settled' after 'carefully testing' left- and right-handed machine screws in a torsion balance
gabriel_laddel: The Eot-wash group won't test this. And the string theorist in that stackoverflow question is more than happy to state that because a large construction of molecules falls at the speed we expect it to, it couldn't possibly happen on a small scale.
asciilifeform: or rather, the question of nonexistence as 'settled'
asciilifeform: gabriel_laddel: the interesting thing, and important to explain mircea_popescu's puzzlement, is that the enemy has been studiously arranging experiments to avoid actually testing the effect in question and declaring it 'settled'
gabriel_laddel: But you have to test it.
gabriel_laddel: What Al would like to test is pretty simple. Is gravity mirror-symmetric? If it is, then you can drop two stereoisomers in a vacuum, and they'll fall at the same rate. We don't know that this is the case, and the universe actually violates mirror-symmetry on many scales. Perhaps a violation will be observable.
assbot: organic chemistry - what is the simple enantiomer in the powder form that one can get? - Chemistry Stack Exchange ... ( http://bit.ly/1CbyBAs )
asciilifeform: http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/chiral2.gif http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/schwart3.png << for those who can do 'crosseye'
asciilifeform: anyone who still gives a damn - read the paper.
asciilifeform: and, incidentally, there are other chiralanes possible (you can generate them as computer model, that is. there is, afaik, no known synthesis for any of them)
asciilifeform: actually my explanation is off, the center is topologically unique. but the thing meets none of the ochem textbook graph-theoretical definitions for chirality
asciilifeform: everyone i ever showed it to
mircea_popescu: but the big ball in teh centre
asciilifeform: (as they typically aren't on a model)
mircea_popescu: what's in the middle, sulphur ?
asciilifeform: that is, each carbon has -exactly the same thing- on all four bonds
asciilifeform: had 'handedness' but no 'chiral centers' - that is, carbon atoms that are topologically 'key'
asciilifeform: phun phact, it broke the definition of 'chirality' taught in schoolbooks
asciilifeform: (whazzat? http://petitjeanmichel.free.fr/itoweb.paper.SCS.2008-4nS.petitjean.pdf << original paper, schwartz & petitjean - they co-invented it)
asciilifeform: from those das
thestringpuller: mircea_popescu: I thought you know storks and stuff...
mircea_popescu: thestringpuller makes you wonder how children were made before they invented shoes.
gabriel_laddel: lemme finish making this burrito and I'll write up something on the game being played
gabriel_laddel: mircea_popescu: did you read the stackoverflow post linked above?
mircea_popescu: gabriel_laddel this is not how it works.
mircea_popescu: this is science not politics, what's biding your time do.
gabriel_laddel: mircea_popescu: the opposition lie through their teeth at every given moment, you don't want to give them anything to work with
thestringpuller: mircea_popescu: how would i learn to play footsie if not via a wikihow article?
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: i confess, i almost decided to
mircea_popescu: not like it's tied to his forehead.
mircea_popescu: suppose i go make the measurement myself ?
mircea_popescu: "biding his time" ?
gabriel_laddel: he isn't giving up, as far as I know, but biding his time
asciilifeform: basically he insisted that a negative result must come from one of the two eotvos torsion balances
mircea_popescu: this can't be a rationale not to try.
gabriel_laddel: iirc, it was an even bet whether the effect - if real - is even large enough to measure with current instrumentation at all << this makes a great deal of sense
mircea_popescu: i hope you're changing the world, schmuckos!
assbot: How to Play Footsie: 5 Steps (with Pictures) - wikiHow ... ( http://bit.ly/1CbvOY2 )
mircea_popescu: check it out, the web2.0 is being useful : http://www.wikihow.com/Play-Footsie
asciilifeform: iirc, it was an even bet whether the effect - if real - is even large enough to measure with current instrumentation at all
mircea_popescu: no, it doesn't. if you try, you gotta try.
asciilifeform: rather than some kid and ratty old instruments from us army
asciilifeform: so if trying, has to be the 'full nine yards'
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: it made sense to me. 'the lysenkoists refuse to even try' is bad enough, but 'see, somebody tried, it failed, shuddup' is quite possibly worse
mircea_popescu: asciilifeform i dun follow this logic.
pete_dushenski: mircea_popescu stoner paratrooper << fighters have a lot of relaxing to do!
asciilifeform: and the man can speak for himself, and really ought to
asciilifeform: anyone who wants to know what was going through his head - write to him! i don't relish playing 'broken telephone'
asciilifeform: that is, that a failure for any number of reasons unrelated to the physical prediction - such as my hands growing out of my arse - would set him back (if such a thing were possible) years
asciilifeform: he understood that it wasn't free
mircea_popescu: i don't get it. he didn't want the experiment made in the end ?
asciilifeform: synthetic crystal of two chiral isomers of $censored that would have, according to the model, very small difference in energy of phase change
mircea_popescu: re alexa : last time i measured their accuracy, it came out to about 96% error rating. ie, if alexa reads 100, it can see anything between 4 and 2500.
asciilifeform: well, he would have had to blow a rather expensive single-use wad
asciilifeform: but al didn't want to pursue
asciilifeform: i actually worked with a number of folks at the time who were ready to wangle access to the instruments for me.
mircea_popescu: and ironically, it's the environment i grew up in.
asciilifeform: it was a perfectly valid objection, which is why the experiment will not happen publicly on this side of the coming civilizational demolition.
mircea_popescu: incidentally, in the ideal model which sits at the fundament of us academia, this would have been arranged over a phone call and tried the next week.
asciilifeform: (most of the 50k, in case anyone cares, covers two well-used microcalorimeters.)
mircea_popescu: and that ftr is a valid objection.
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: al ended up having to explain to me... well, the concept i outlined in the first thread re: this subject here in #b-a
asciilifeform: mircea_popescu: i devised a test costing approximately 50k usd.
mircea_popescu: <asciilifeform> that could easily be tested. << not easily, no. but yes, they could be.
mircea_popescu: think of it in terms of throwing bowling balls at a tree from outer space. you won't get within a mile. and if the first ball lands 735`331meters rom the tree, the next five won't land 735`331 meters from the next five threes.
mircea_popescu: gabriel_laddel string theorists are a lot like freudian psychanalists. the better ones follow the lieberman line.